The pros and cons of renovation versus a new build

At some point in your life you will probably find yourself asking – should I buy a new build or instead consider a renovation project?

Perhaps you’re a first time buyer unsure which option is right for you, or maybe you’re already a home owner undecided whether your second home should be a repeat of your initial decision or something different.

It’s not always an easy or obvious decision to make as you may not have an existing strong preference. Therefore, I have explored the pros and cons of both options in more detail below to assist with your decision making.

New Build – The Pros

  • Be the first to occupy the building! No previous owners or tenants to worry about meaning you can move straight in. It should also be left tidy and clean as the developers will have a vested interest in your satisfaction.
  • No onward chains to complicate the house buying process – this is particularly appealing to first time buyers as the availability of the house being purchased is not dependant on another being sold.
  • It’s brand new – everything will be fresh and clean ready to be lived in from the get go.
  • Personal decor choices – during the build there will be opportunities to choose features such as your kitchen appliances, bathroom fittings and flooring options. The house will also be a blank canvas as most walls will be painted with a neutral palette.
  • Everything will be modern and convenient – new build layouts are designed for modern living with open spaces.
  • Built with today’s health and safety standards – often come with a builder’s guarantee to give you peace of mind.

Renovation – The Pros

  • More solid and better built – older houses usually hold qualities that have been lost in modern designs.
  • More spacious – while older houses are often made up of more separate rooms they do tend to be bigger in size with more floor space and storage.
  • Personalisation of property – if you’re carrying out a full renovation then you can literally start from scratch and choose everything exactly as you want it (budget permitting)
  • Hands on or hands off – you may feel up to the challenge of renovating yourself, but if you would rather not get messy, then it’s simple enough to find tradespeople to do the work for you! If you’re undecided whether you should renovate a house yourself or hire a professional then please read here for guidance.
  • Character and charm – there’s no denying that period houses provide beautiful features that new builds don’t (but then I may be biased here!)
  • Service charges are more manageable – if you’re considering buying a flat then the costs are often more affordable on older properties.
  • Investment – older houses are usually better money makers as you can ‘add value’ with the renovations you carry out.

New build – The Cons

  • They’re built quickly – and for this reason may not be as solid or stable as an older property.
  • Snagging list – new builds usually present a number of issues such as settling in cracks which will need to be seen to after you’ve moved in.
  • Can be approximately 20-25% more expensive – you’re often paying for the convenience and ‘newness’ of the property.
  • Possibility for negative equity – there have been warnings regarding the government’s help to buy scheme so please be wary of this.
  • High service charge – monthly fees for the upkeep of the glamourously designed buildings, gardens and parks are common and can be expensive. This can also cause issues when selling the property on.
  • Location – new build developments may be squeezed into less desirable areas such as the outskirts of towns and cities with no nearby amenities.
  • Pricey decor/appliances – buying your appliances via another source could prove to be much cheaper and will provide more options.
  • Buying off plan – as your house is probably not built yet you will need to make a decision based on plans of how it should look and promises of the quality.
  • Showrooms can be misleading – professionals that dress the rooms in a show home are very skilled at creating illusions of more space.
  • Smaller rooms – in order to fit more houses on to a plot, due to investment purposes for the developer, rooms are usually smaller than older builds.
  • Potential for delays – there is often a knock on effect during a development which may mean that your home takes much longer to build than anticipated.

Renovation – The Cons

  • Damp, dark, dreary, and dated – older built houses in need of renovation are cheaper for a reason and you will need to deal with a variety of tasks in order to create a comfortable living space. Be prepared to have to see through this and imagine the potential!
  • Planning permission needed for extensions – if you want to expand the current building then it is essential that you gain approval before going ahead to avoid any legal implications.
  • Be careful about area and neighbours – ‘Buy the worst house on the best street’ is cracking advice for those looking to renovate.
  • Building survey required – this is advised to ensure there are no issues (such as asbestos or Japanese Knotweed) which could cause you problems in future.
  • Renovation work can be expensive and it is easy to go over budget – savings can get used up very quickly so it’s important to be realistic about how much you are able to spend.
  • Lots of effort required – even if you’re having the work carried out by builders, renovation involves a lot of project management and potential stress so be warned! To see just what can be involved, take a look at our experience here.
  • Alternative accommodation needed or live in and amongst the destruction! Not everyone is lucky enough to be able to move back in with their parents to be able to renovate before moving in, so it’s important to think about living arrangements, especially if you’re ripping out important parts of the home such as the kitchen and bathroom.

So, there you have it! A fairly in-depth look at the pros and cons of renovation and new builds. Yes, there are many factors to consider, such as time, finance, and taste, but there is no such thing as a wrong decision, as you will learn so much whichever route you take. However, the above should enable you to decide which option feels right for you based on your current circumstances.

I’d love to hear your preferences regarding buying a new build or a renovation project. Let me know in the comments below!

The Renovation – Phase Three

Blimey… it’s been almost two months since I last blogged. You can tell that life is starting to return to some form of normality after lockdown, whatever that might be!

Anyway, I’m desperate to tell you all about the next phase of our renovation, so I’ve managed to secure a bit of peace and quiet this Sunday afternoon to finally get it written down.

Just as a recap, in case you haven’t read my latest renovation post, the plasterers had been and gone, and the first fix of electrics had been completed. Most walls were now reinstated and our 1930s shell was starting to look more like a house once again.

So firstly, say hello to our new doors! These oak beauties from XL Joinery have been hung in every room of the house (as well as a glass panel version from our hall into our dining room) and they really tie everything together. The soft wood tones with our chrome handles from Dale Joinery create a stylish consistency throughout and are a certain improvement from the hollow walnut doors of my nightmares that were left previously!

The next step following the plastering was mist coating! It’s amazing how much of a difference this phase makes. The rooms feel like they double in size and you really start to realise their potential. This is an essential step if you’ve freshly plastered so make sure not to miss it if you’re doing a renovation yourself. Simply water down a white emulsion paint to seal the walls and prevent any peeling.

It’s so funny looking back at our archive of photos as I can remember the excitement as each puzzle piece was added and the finish line became closer and closer. It’s such a warm fuzzy feeling so I apologise if I describe 90% of the renovation works as ‘exciting’.

We wanted a luxury feel to our bathroom so these marble effect tiles from B&Q were the perfect choice. Available in two shades, we used the darker tiles for the floor, and the lighter ones for the walls in order to create a bit more depth. We also thought the grey tones would suit the chrome taps and fittings that we had chosen.

However, while certain elements were coming together, there was still major destruction downstairs… check out the alfresco toilet! Don’t you agree that it’s a rather strange choice to put a downstairs loo in the kitchen? Safe to say we pulled that out rather quickly to gain more space and move the unpleasantness away from our cooking space!!

As mentioned before, the flooring levels in this space were ridiculously uneven so it was necessary to knock through the concrete flooring, so our builder could add floor joists to sort the issue. Fortunately for us, there were plenty of salvageable floorboards throughout the property, so we planned to reinstate these in our kitchen/diner. Restoring as much of the house as possible was really important to us, so to be able to reuse the floorboards was an absolute dream.

Here’s a further peek at the marble tiles on the walls and parts of the bathroom being installed. We actually reused the toilet from the previous owners as it was pretty new – a little cost saving (although we replaced the seat, don’t worry!)! I won’t say too much more about the bathroom, but I couldn’t help but show off a little more of the progress!

I’ve already gushed about the floorboards quite a lot in this post so it wouldn’t be fair to leave you without featuring them! There was a real mixture of colours from where they’d been painted over the years but nothing an industrial sander wouldn’t sort. Look how well they’ve all pieced together – they’re really going to help open up the space while pulling the two separate rooms together in one space.

Well, I think I’ll have to leave you on a bit of a cliffhanger here, as you’ll need to come back soon to see the finished floorboards, but hopefully it’s been interesting to see a little more of our journey.

However, if you have any questions at all about our renovation, then please don’t hesitate to leave a comment, and I’ll be more than happy to help!

The Renovation – Phase Two

So, we’d knocked a lot of walls over and pulled all ceilings down, but what happened next?

Well, when we removed all the carpet, we were delighted to find a variety of original floorboards in many of the rooms, such as the bedrooms and lounge. My partner’s Dad suggested we used these for the flooring in the kitchen/dining room, which would not only maintain a traditional element of the house, but also provide a big cost saving due to the size of the area.

However, this meant that the floorboards would need ripping up, and replacing with chipboard flooring in the rooms they had come from. Frighteningly, for a short while, the upstairs of our home was visible from the downstairs rooms! In the photo, you can see how we literally took the house back to the outside walls and joists, at this point!


As we were going to be relaying the floorboards, we needed to ensure the kitchen and dining room floor was level, which it certainly was not! It didn’t effect us too much luckily, but when we took up the existing flooring, we found that the extension built in the 90s was not constructed very well, and there was a clear slope from the dining room into the kitchen.

This was a time consuming job, and my Dad was roped in to help dig the concrete flooring, so that my partner’s Dad could create floor joists in the dining room to solve the problem. However, if we wanted our open plan kitchen and dining room, this was necessary work that had to be done (Dad still has nightmares about this as he lost his thumbnail from all the hammering – so sorry!).

Upstairs, it was also necessary to rebuild the studwork for the bathroom wall, which we had taken away to extend into the second bedroom (you can read about that here). This enabled us to create more space ready for our walk-in shower. Unfortunately, as we extended into the second bedroom and the shower was mounted on an outside wall, we were unable to have recessed shelves like I’d hoped (a minor disappointment in the grand scheme of things!).

As the house was built in the 1930s, we didn’t feel comfortable with trusting the existing electrics, and also wanted to make amendments to the plumbing. For those of you that have read my previous blog post, you’ll know that there are certain elements of a house build where you may feel more comfortable relying on a trained tradesman. Hands up, these were two jobs that we did not want to tackle ourselves!

The majority of the plumbing work happened when all the walls were dismantled, whereas the first fix of the electrics was carried out once the plasterboard was in place. It’s so hard to decide where you want the plug sockets to go when you’ve never lived in the house and there are no walls to to help you envisage their placement! It turns out that 90% of the house got rewired in the end! The plumber had to reefed pipes into the bathroom and kitchen, and also relocated a number of radiators.

One of my requests was that the upvc windowsills were replaced with pine, as I felt this would be much more in keeping with the rest of the house. I’m so glad that we did, as they are subtle and traditional, and align with the architraves and skirting. We needed to make sure these were in place before the plastering could be done.

Thankfully, my partner and his Dad were able to do all the plasterboarding and they also sorted the blue grit to save on cost, but again, we felt it was important to hire professional plasterers to get the finish spot on. It’s amazing how much the house changes after the plasterers have been and gone!

It’s crazy to think how much hard work goes on behind the scenes that you don’t consider when you view a finished house! I’m so glad I took plenty of photos to document the process, as I’m not sure some of our family and friends would have believed what went on! Have you had a similar experience with your renovation?

If there’s anything about this phase of our journey that you’d like to know more about, then please don’t hesitate to let me know in the comments, and I’d be happy to help!

Follow my blog with Bloglovin

Can you renovate a house yourself? Or should you hire a professional?

Perhaps you’re considering whether you should take on a renovation project or opt for a new build? While both have their positives and negatives, renovations are often a popular choice, as they can be significantly cheaper, and present the opportunity to put a stamp on your home.

However, undertaking a house renovation can present many dilemmas and challenges before you have even begun. It’s important to consider a multitude of things before going ahead and securing an offer on a tired and rundown house.

One of those initial decisions should be whether you intend to renovate the house yourself, or instead hire a team of professional tradespeople to carry out the work. Here, we help you decide which way you’re going to attempt a fixer upper!

Write a pros and cons list

Again, both have their advantages and disadvantages, so one of The Renovation Lab’s top tips is to write a pros and cons list. Weigh up the options and you will soon be able to see which list makes you feel more comfortable.

If you’re on a low budget, then undertaking tasks yourself can provide huge savings, and there are plenty of great tutorials on the Internet to guide you along the way.  Maybe money isn’t such an issue, but you’re tight for time, and getting the professionals in will speed up your transformation.

It’s important to make the decision that is right for you and your goals so this list will ensure you get your priorities in order.

Consider a mix and match method

While you may feel your handy skills stretch to stripping wallpaper and ripping out the old kitchen units, it is usually best to call in a professional to take down any supporting walls, or contact the experts for plastering. Nobody likes an uneven wall, and it will bug you forever, so it often pays to invest in the right assistance.

Write a list of all the tasks you expect to encounter during your renovation and jot down where you think you will need professional help. This can help you see where costs are likely to arise, but also where you can save some funds by getting your hands dirty.

This article gives fantastic advice about what you can tackle yourself and what is best to leave to the pros.

Call on friends for support

Our decision was made easy for us, as we have a builder in the family, as well as a number of close friends in the trade. As they say, it’s not what you know, it’s who you know, and we found this to be especially true!  You’ll be surprised how many people are willing to lend a hand, especially if you offer an incentive or two, such as one day returning the favour!

While we appreciate everyone might not be so lucky, it’s also worth asking friends for recommendations of reliable tradespeople, as knowing someone you trust has experienced a positive service will give you peace of mind.

Utilise your expertise

Are you a fine artist in your spare time? Then why not try exchanging your fine paintbrush, for one with a thicker handle, and save yourself some cash at the same time. It can feel like a real accomplishment when you make changes to your own home, especially when you sit back and reap the benefits when it’s all finished.

I don’t have any particular DIY skills, let’s be honest, but I was given the job of sanding the staircase spindles and banister. This was mainly due to my personality trait of being a perfectionist, which meant I was determined to get rid of as many layers of varnish as possible, and make sure everything was neatly sanded before we primed and painted. Use your abilities to your advantage!

Consider building regulations

You might be confident that you can carry out the physical task of a renovation, but it’s imperative that your knowledge is also up to date and that your build complies with any necessary legal requirements. We highly recommend that you consult with any professionals when it comes to extensions and other similar endeavors.

It would be heartbreaking for all your hard work to be undone, following a visit from the building inspector, when it isn’t up to their strict standards. If you’re preparing to improve your home then there is a wealth of useful information regarding planning permission on the Citizen’s Advice website.

Be prepared to project manage

If you are looking to hire professionals to help with renovation work for particular tasks, please be prepared to project manage. Organisation is also key. If your electrician is ready to second fix, but your plasterer has phoned to say they’re not available for another month, then you have a problem on your hands. Delays are inevitable, but you must be willing to be flexible, while also being firm enough to ensure the project keeps moving and the jobs get done.

It can sometimes feel easier to ask for favours from friends and relatives in this instance, but often they can be the hardest to manage, for fear of feeling cheeky or applying too much pressure. Just something to bear in mind when scheduling each phase of your renovation.

The scope of the project

Let’s say you’re capable of carrying out the works on your renovation venture. If you are planning a large-scale project, then you may need more than your single pair of hands, or the help of your friend, parent or partner.

If you’re working towards a tight deadline, then it can pay to have additional workers on site; so more than one task can be tackled at a time. However, some builders may like to be left to their own devices, so check out their preferences before you assume they will work with you.

DIY renovation vs. professional contractor

Hopefully this article has given you a starting point from which to begin investigating the best option for you. Everyone is different, so what may be right for someone else, may not be right for you.  Therefore, it’s really important that you take the time to figure out a strategy before you steam ahead.

With all that being said, please don’t be afraid to give renovation a go. It’s incredibly rewarding, whether you decide to give it a go yourself, or hand over the responsibility to the professionals. You’re in charge of the decisions and that’s the most important thing when making a house your home.

What did you decide to do? Let me know in the comments!

Getting started…the destruction phase!

I’ll never forget my partner’s Dad’s words…

“I’ve just devalued your house by about £40k in 48 hours!”


The pace at which two guys managed to dismantle the walls and ceilings was quite frankly unbelievable! The house was a shell of its former self in what felt like minutes.

At first, we thought we would simply need to redecorate, but soon discovered that the existing walls were constructed of lath and plaster (narrow strips of wood are nailed to the stud walls or ceiling joists and are then coated with plaster – very old fashioned!).

While we could have simply painted or wallpapered over this, our builder suggested we do a ‘proper job’ (said in a Devonshire accent), and start with a clean slate. It was going to be a lot more time consuming, but would provide us with a much better finish, so we happily took his advice.

It was a messy process to say the least, causing a mega tonne of dust, with rubbish filling reams and reams of rubble bags. However, the latter could be used as kindle wood, which saved us many trips to the recycling centre, as many friends and relatives were quick to take this off our hands.

If you’ve gone through a renovation yourself, you’ll know that the sheer amount of tidying required seems never ending, but there is something so satisfying about removing all the old material. Very cleansing for the soul!

For the most part, the structure of the house would be staying the same, but there were a couple of walls that needed knocking down completely, to achieve our desired layout.

In my previous post, you can see how the house looked when we purchased it, and you will find a photo of the tiny bathroom. It was important to us that this room was made bigger, so we decided that we would extend into the second bedroom, by the width of a shower tray.

The idea was to install a walk-in shower with a glass panel to give the illusion of more space. We removed the studwork here, and in the photo below you can see the makeshift timber marker on the floor, which shows where the new divide will sit.

The next wall on the deconstruction list was the one that separated the kitchen from the dining room. We had lusted after an open social space so this was our answer! Luckily for us, it was a badly constructed breeze block wall (it had been part of an extension), so it fell down without too much effort. The door into the dining room would later be boarded up so that there was just one entrance into the new hub of our home.

Admittedly, this hasn’t been the prettiest of blog posts, but I think there’s something so fascinating about seeing the stripped back insides of an older property, and what really goes into renovating a home behind the scenes!

If you have a similar post sharing your renovation journey, I’d love to read, so please share in the comments below.

1930s terraced House

Number Twelve – The ‘Before’

My first home.

Picking up the keys has to be one of the proudest moments of my life. Opening the door for the first time without the presence of an estate agent. Sitting on the stairs, taking in the surroundings, without a want of being anywhere else but in your very own four walls. A feeling I will never forget.

We had decided to take on a project. With a builder in the family, and a want to put our own stamp on things, the decision was a pretty easy one. Plus, the idea of being able to add value to our new investment, was very appealing too.

Silently agreeing during the first viewing that this was the house for us, we put in our initial offer, and with a little to-ing and fro-ing came to an agreed price. We recognised the potential straight away, and fell in love with the spacious layout of the three bed terrace, along with its 1930s quirks.

The property had previously been a rental, so it was liveable, but the decor was dated and tired. The kitchen was narrow and had an odd downstairs loo within it, so we planned to remove the toilet, and knock down the wall between the kitchen/diner to open up the space. The flooring throughout certainly needed a refresh and the walls would need redecorating, but initially the amount of work didn’t seem too overwhelming.

However, on second thoughts, the more we looked at it, the more we felt that we wanted to do it ‘properly’. The to do list soon doubled! From rewiring the electrics and replacing plumbing, to taking the walls and ceilings right back to the studwork, it seemed foolish not to when we had access to friends in the trade and just enough in the budget to cover it.

Despite the garish floral wallpaper and ugly gas fireplaces, hopefully you too can see why we fell in love with the house, and imagine the full potential it has! I’ll be back very soon with more details and photos of our extensive renovation journey.

Please tell me the stories of buying your first home in the comments below. I’d love to hear them! You can also find out more about me here.